Talking data

Sustaining the richness of the humanities

At Digital Humanities 2010 I recorded quite a bit of focused attention to sustainability. My own contribution was a challenge to think differently about how sustainability is likely to be realised, using ideas from biological evolution and multi-agent games. In the digital world, every access involves the making of a copy. If we could tweak things in such a way that all these copies positively contributed to the preservation of the corresponding resource, then we would wield tremendous power for the good of preservation. The abstract is online and expect the presentation there as well, shortly.

In several other lectures I heard two very different approaches to sustainability. In 
The Specimen Case and the Garden: Preserving Complex Digital Objects, Sustaining Digital Projects Lewis Ulman eloquently advocated an approach that I have always found right, but lately I have begun to doubt it. In (very) short: a humanities project typically delivers a rich interconnected set of materials in many media, accessible through a (web)-interface that let you explore everything in its connectedness. The web-interface is likely to die off at some time, and the best you can do is to document all relationships, store the documentation with the data, so that posterity will not have much trouble to redevelop an interface for the web of materials.

What is wrong with this? Well, it is not really wrong, in fact it is infinitely better than taking no particular measures, but what I do see happen in the distant future is this: a researcher issues a query, finds among his search results an XML document from the project's frozen result. He wants to explore the related materials of the project, but there is no interface. He sees that there is documentation how to build a web interface, but the documentation refers to obsolete architectures and systems, and the researcher is not in a position to dedicate that kind of effort needed to do it. On to the next search result ...

Can we do better?

At least two talks pointed to an other way. In 
The Open Annotation Collaboration: A Data Model to Support Sharing and Interoperability of Scholarly Annotations Jane Hunter proposed a new way to handle annotations: OpenAnnotation. A web based, collaborative, transparent, explicit, standardized paradigm to represent scholarly annotations to just any resource that is representable on the web, be it pieces of texts, sections of images, cuts of videos, or sets of other resources.
And in the same room, Peter Robinson and Federico Meschini presented 
Works, Documents, Texts and Related Resources for Everyone and made proposals that might help the paradigm of the Semantic Web and Linked Data come true in the library world.

Now reconsider the typical output of a humanities project. If we manage to do the annotations in the Open Annotations way, and if we manage to express the relation web through the formalisms of Linked Data, then we do not need special purpose interfaces for the output materials. These formalisms are built directly on top of mainstream web technology, but are more basic than the formalisms found in specific disciplines. As such, I expect that at this level we'll see a new layer of infrastructure emerging. Part of that infrastructure will also be the facility of temporal browsing, i.e. directing your browsing to points in the past, in order to surf the archived web at that point in time. See 
the memento idea by Herbert van de Sompel and others.

There will be very generic interfaces based on Linked Data, and these interfaces are flexible enough to absorb new relationships and datastructures.

The data is now freed from the interface, the interfaces are (meta)data driven, and our future researcher has an instant view on the richness of an old resource.

One challenge remains, in my opinion: how do we make sure that this new infrastructure is really sustainable? I admit that I have only a clouded vision on this: let there be a new kind of cloud, with workspaces for users that collect works that interest them. Let the cloud be smart, in that it implements the new infrastructure. Let the cloud be efficient in that it optimises the copies of works for storage economy, but also for access economy. And let the cloud be honest and creative in dividing the costs over all workspaces, charging users for storage, but also paying users for their contribution to the preservation of the works they copy.

This is truly revolutionary: to be paid for storing a copy of a preservation worthy work. 

431 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 431 of 431
Anonymous said...

귀하의 블로그는 중요합니다 .. 레깅스 룸

Anonymous said...

유용한 정보에 감사드립니다. 토토

Anonymous said...

This is an interesting post that I'll like to share with you LOCKSMITH YORK

Anonymous said...

귀하의 블로그는 중요합니다 .. 토토사이트

Anonymous said...

Thank you for very usefull information.. 메이저사이트

Karina brivio said...

This was a really great contest and hopefully I can attend the next one ver hentai

Anonymous said...

감동 받았습니다. 아주 드물게 유익하고 재미있는 블로그를 접하는 경우가 거의 없습니다. 귀하의 블로그는 중요합니다 .. 먹튀검증

Fairy Alex said...

Hello! I'm a new user here, and I appreciate the suggestions you made in this article. So that my friend Liana can read this kind of intriguing blog post, I'm going to forward her your website's link. I'm currently in need assignment writing service in newcastle to complete a task that is due tomorrow. I'm hopeful that this business will do my work in a timely manner.

360 Dissertations said...

It's time to say the obvious, I suppose. The PhD thesis services you obtain from Personal Thesis Coach in Bangalore give you assistance if you do not know where to start from because you have already started when you come to this site. Now, let us guide you further.

Bokep di bawah said...

Game judi slot online is the most complete and has become a true online slot gambling center, playing slot plans with only a small capital of 10-,0000

Xanime said...

I’m pleased by your article and hope you write more like it xanimeporn

Fabiola Braganini said...

this is nice to see.
When a content is made with interest, it always turns out well
thanks for sharing this great site we have here itadaki seieki

5lqu5eeodi said...

The anticipation is building with only a couple brief months to go until Ohio sports activities betting, and bettors can prepare by downloading the Caesars Sportsbook app right now. Oddsmakers on the leading sportsbooks will weigh up the strengths of both groups. They concentrate on to} offensive and defensive 빙고 capabilities, current outcomes, head-to-heads, injury news, residence benefit and different necessary elements.

Lucia Botto said...

Thanks lots this web site is definitely formal and also simple hentai

Bhanu Prakash said...

Amazing article
Mincecraft MOD APK

Job suraksha said...

Thanks For sharing this Superb article. Hiring for backend hr profile backend operations in jammu and kashmir

William Buyer said...

Excellent blog. Thank you for sharing this information through this blog. Every line contains valuable information. Do you have trouble finishing your dissertation? You are now in the right location. We provide the best dissertation help for Australian collage students, enabling students to easily complete challenging dissertation help. Our writer also provides plazarism free and error free content.

Valeria Mane said...

I’m really enjoying the design and layout of your blog hentaimama

Gary Ralph said...

Easiest way to trade your tokens and supported by 22 networks.
Sushiswap
Polygon Wallet
Phantom Wallet
Quickswap

William Buyer said...

Thank you for sharing useful material, and I am very impressed with the articles that you serve. Finding difficulty to solve your college dissertation. Here we bring the solution to your college dissertation.You can hire an expert to solve your dissertation help Australia. Also, Our writers will give you error-free and plagiarism-free content.

okbetsports.ph said...

Very interesting information! Perfect just what I was looking for! My site: okbet manila

Gary Ralph said...

Our innovationYoroi is a light wallet for Cardano. There is no need to download the blockchain when you open the wallet.
Yoroiwallet

Breitbart News said...

The MetaMask wallet is excellent for individuals MetaMask wallet | American Express Login

Breitbart News said...

MetaMask wallet | American Express Login

hatena said...

I hope you will continue to write such good articles as well hentai stream

r65dbf0pn1 said...

If you create an account from Facebook, the app offers you a large quantity of|numerous|a lot of} free coins. Exclusively for Thunder Rewards Club Members taking part in} with their card, each slot in the house is wired into our thrilling progressive Thunder Strike Jackpot. Thunder can strike on any slot, at any time, with a payout between $50,000 and $150,000. With a fast 카지노사이트 hit price of 5 jackpots per hour, this slot machine sport has to offer plenty of options and options.

Gary Ralph said...

ShibaSwap acts as the native Ethereum-based decentralized exchange (DEX) of the Shiba Inu project.Sushi offers a user-friendly AMM, allowing users to easily trade crypto assets.
shibaswap
sushiswap

casinositewiki said...


Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon everyday.카지노사이트위키

wispergreen said...

Use Metamask Sign In key vault, secure login and digital wallet to manage your digital assets. Metamask Sign In | Citicard Login

sofya rose said...


The MetaMask wallet is excellent for individuals who are familiar with cryptocurrencies, MetaMask wallet | American Express Login

sofya rose said...


The MetaMask wallet is excellent for individuals who are familiar with cryptocurrencies, MetaMask wallet | American Express Login

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 431 of 431   Newer› Newest»

Post a Comment