Talking data

Sustaining the richness of the humanities

At Digital Humanities 2010 I recorded quite a bit of focused attention to sustainability. My own contribution was a challenge to think differently about how sustainability is likely to be realised, using ideas from biological evolution and multi-agent games. In the digital world, every access involves the making of a copy. If we could tweak things in such a way that all these copies positively contributed to the preservation of the corresponding resource, then we would wield tremendous power for the good of preservation. The abstract is online and expect the presentation there as well, shortly.

In several other lectures I heard two very different approaches to sustainability. In 
The Specimen Case and the Garden: Preserving Complex Digital Objects, Sustaining Digital Projects Lewis Ulman eloquently advocated an approach that I have always found right, but lately I have begun to doubt it. In (very) short: a humanities project typically delivers a rich interconnected set of materials in many media, accessible through a (web)-interface that let you explore everything in its connectedness. The web-interface is likely to die off at some time, and the best you can do is to document all relationships, store the documentation with the data, so that posterity will not have much trouble to redevelop an interface for the web of materials.

What is wrong with this? Well, it is not really wrong, in fact it is infinitely better than taking no particular measures, but what I do see happen in the distant future is this: a researcher issues a query, finds among his search results an XML document from the project's frozen result. He wants to explore the related materials of the project, but there is no interface. He sees that there is documentation how to build a web interface, but the documentation refers to obsolete architectures and systems, and the researcher is not in a position to dedicate that kind of effort needed to do it. On to the next search result ...

Can we do better?

At least two talks pointed to an other way. In 
The Open Annotation Collaboration: A Data Model to Support Sharing and Interoperability of Scholarly Annotations Jane Hunter proposed a new way to handle annotations: OpenAnnotation. A web based, collaborative, transparent, explicit, standardized paradigm to represent scholarly annotations to just any resource that is representable on the web, be it pieces of texts, sections of images, cuts of videos, or sets of other resources.
And in the same room, Peter Robinson and Federico Meschini presented 
Works, Documents, Texts and Related Resources for Everyone and made proposals that might help the paradigm of the Semantic Web and Linked Data come true in the library world.

Now reconsider the typical output of a humanities project. If we manage to do the annotations in the Open Annotations way, and if we manage to express the relation web through the formalisms of Linked Data, then we do not need special purpose interfaces for the output materials. These formalisms are built directly on top of mainstream web technology, but are more basic than the formalisms found in specific disciplines. As such, I expect that at this level we'll see a new layer of infrastructure emerging. Part of that infrastructure will also be the facility of temporal browsing, i.e. directing your browsing to points in the past, in order to surf the archived web at that point in time. See 
the memento idea by Herbert van de Sompel and others.

There will be very generic interfaces based on Linked Data, and these interfaces are flexible enough to absorb new relationships and datastructures.

The data is now freed from the interface, the interfaces are (meta)data driven, and our future researcher has an instant view on the richness of an old resource.

One challenge remains, in my opinion: how do we make sure that this new infrastructure is really sustainable? I admit that I have only a clouded vision on this: let there be a new kind of cloud, with workspaces for users that collect works that interest them. Let the cloud be smart, in that it implements the new infrastructure. Let the cloud be efficient in that it optimises the copies of works for storage economy, but also for access economy. And let the cloud be honest and creative in dividing the costs over all workspaces, charging users for storage, but also paying users for their contribution to the preservation of the works they copy.

This is truly revolutionary: to be paid for storing a copy of a preservation worthy work. 

51 comments:

Charles van den Heuvel said...

Hi Dirk
Interesting. I am not so sure yet whether it would be an advantage "to be freed from interfaces" as Peter Robinson stated. I am very much in favor of the proposed architecture of the Open Annotation Consortium. Really great stuff, but the smoothless integrations should be in the back end in my view. I believe that it is still relevant for the user to have an interface to allow she/him to select specific "filtered" information to avoid overkill that is not relevant for the research in question.

Dirk Roorda @ DANS said...

Good point. At least the improved back-end frees us from the nightmare of preserving those interfaces indefinitely.

Lewis said...

Hi, Dirk. Thanks for tying so much of the work on sustainability together in your post! Note that Melanie and I proposed a two-pronged approach. The one you describe (the specimen case that preserves a particular historical instantiation of a project) and a more evolutionary approach that enlists institutional curators who manage inevitable change over time. Underlying all of the choices you describe in your post, I suppose, are choices about what is being sustained or preserved. Literary scholars are interested in works, texts, editions, book arts, and literary culture, and different sorts of evidence are needed to construct interpretations of each. Some scholars may indeed want to know something not only about the interpretations recorded in a TEI transcription or Open Annotation but also about the physical systems by which those interpretations were presented to and received by readers. For that, we need the "specimen case" approach. If we want to sustain the normal development of DH projects, we will need to provide some mechanism by which they can continue to respond to changing conditions after their original developers are no longer involved -- and you have noted several of the approaches currently on the table. Your use of the metaphor of evolution is instructive. Evolution is simply a mechanism that life on Earth -- in general -- developed that allows it to persist in the face of changing environmental conditions. But the analogy only serves us so far. In the long run, evolution hasn't sustained individuals or species; it has provided enough variation in the gene pool broadly conceived to allow life to diversify -- and therefore persist -- in response to changing conditions. Evolution has yielded human behaviors that have allowed us to sustain ourselves so far, but in order to understand how we got here, we have had to turn to fossil records that reveal previous states -- and we have those records only because of some physical processes that by chance preserved some of them for us. Paleontologists would love to have a more complete record, even if it wouldn't allow them to reanimate early hominids :-).

Term Paper Writing Services said...

Professional Health and Safety Writing Services is very popular for students in search of healthcare and safety research paper writing services and health and safety essay writing services.

Scat Rogger said...

Amore Jewelry offers a great selection of Women Costume Jewelry at affordable pricing. Vast selection of bracelets, charms, earrings, necklaces, rings and more.

Taylor Johnson said...

It is essential to gather essential information to cite the dissertation as per the MLA referencing style. Include the following information: name of the author, title of the dissertation, date of publication, institution granting the degree, description of the work (optional), database and URL if accessed through a database or repository.

Allessaywriter.com is dedicated to offering premium quality essay writer across all genres, including cause and effect, descriptive, comparative, argumentative and more. If you need flawlessly drafted and well-referenced essay writing at the best price, look nowhere else, and count on us.


johnmiller said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
johnmiller said...

Writing a research paper is definitely a brainstorming process for students. To get a high grade, you should take research essay help from experts. Their expert guidance and unlimited support will help you in your paper. your research paper needs a logical and unique ending. Here, the cheap essay writing service should point out the primary factors and end them accordingly.

Noah Brown said...

Bamboo Boulder™ is your one-stop solution to buy Bamboo & Wooden Home Supplies. Get Wooden Home Decor Supplies at a discounted price. VISIT US NOW!!

Monnika Jacob said...

In the digital world where messaging has become so fast, why is it taking so long for people to realize that human survival is linked to wildlife? Essay Writing Service

Kaylee Brown said...

If you are hearing about accounting assignment help for the first time, you might think that this is very expensive as you get non-plagiarized and quality content delivered to you within hours. You would be surprised to know that these accounting assignment help service is very much affordable and, any college or school student can hire an accounting assignment helper without burning away all the savings. The price for completing the assignment will also depend on the delivery date you choose and the length of the assignment.

linda parker said...

The secret for student success lies in the material you use for learning.Try Test Bank For The Developing Person Through The Life Span 10th Edition and feel the difference.

Taylor Johnson said...

Our international human rights law assignment essay help experts describe the salient privileges that international human rights offer:

Unknown said...

Nice Blog. Thanks for sharing with us. Such amazing information.

Skills you need to possess to be a quality content writer

bellacallen said...

Wonderful Post. Thanks for giving me this information. Keep sharing such type of information.
Facebook is accessed by every category user. Whether you are a kid, small businessman, an employee, or a big business tycoon. Depending upon your needs and deeds, Facebook offers services at the best of your convenience. Every time to help you out in solving your technical concerns, or behavioral issues, Facebook Customer Care Number is right here.

Emberly Joe said...

Our team provides the best Research Paper Help.

Michael said...

If you are unfamiliar with law essay writing service uk, you may believe that it is prohibitively expensive because you receive non-plagiarized and high-quality content within hours. You'll be surprised to learn that these law essay are extremely affordable, and that any college or high school student can hire an accounting assignment helper without blowing their entire savings account. The cost of finishing the task will also be determined by the deadline you select and the length of the work.

Kaylee Brown said...

Monetary repercussions are also a true thing! When you copy a portion of a write up from the internet, you do not check the copyright clause written on the website. If the original author of the paper lodges a complaint against you, you may need to bear monetary penalties. You may have to compensate them with money and the amount won’t be too small! If you are still a student, paying the huge compensation money will be impossible for you. Hence, it is always wise to stay away from plagiarism. Find a finance assignment expert and ask him to finish your assignment on time.

Sara said...

Thanks for such an amazing content. https://www.homatz.co.uk/

Vmagosu said...

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free.

Review my webpage - 국내경마

pachinkosite.info said...

I like what you guys are up also. Such clever work and reporting! Carry on the excellent works guys I've incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it will improve the value of my website. 파친코

blackjacksite.top said...

Well I definitely enjoyed studying it. This information provided by you is very practical for good planning.

온라인카지노

sportstoto.link said...

Great goods from you. I have understand your stuff previous to and you’re just too fantastic. I really like what you have acquired here, certainly like what you are saying and the way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to keep it sensible. 토토

slotmachine777.site said...

Hi there, the whole thing is going well here and of course everyone is sharing information, that’s really fine, keep up writing.

슬롯머신777사이트

Unknown said...

Students can get AutoCAD help from our experts who provide online assignment assistance for this topic. Point clouds refer to a set of points in a coordinate system. These points are defined by X, Y and Z. Our experts are well-acquainted with all the major aspects of this topic. For further assistance, students need to avail our AutoCAD assignments help services online.

Ariz Meservi said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
lennontilly said...

We are a well-known Web Development Company USA, that provides Custom Website Development in Texas, Los Angeles, Florida & California, USA, as we have well-known Web Developers and quality web designers. Select our Website Design Company in USA and your business will certainly be assured of 100% openness. You can totally rely on us for any Website development in Florida because we have a team of professional web developers and designers in our company. Additionally, as the best Web Development Agency California, we provide our clients with the opportunity to show their brand via the best web design and layout in loss Angeles.

Ariz Meservi said...

The base of this service with russian mail order brides is very wide, everyone will probably be able to find their dream bride here, with whom they will build an ideal family. Personally, I myself met my girlfriend here, and she turned out to be not a fake or a bot, which I was very happy with at the first personal meeting. Thanks to this service for bringing two loving hearts together.

Olivia Wilson said...

Programming is providing great opportunities for students to build a career. There is a doubt that information technology has changed the world for the better. Many students who lack the analytical ability and thus they end up seeking programming help. If you are opting for this career, you need to make sure if you have the passion for solving problems and essential knowledge of coding as programming actually demands.

yadongbiz said...

It’s really a nice and useful piece of information. I’m glad that you shared this helpful info with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing. 한국야동

Also feel free to visit may web page 야한동영상

yahanvideonet said...

This is an excellent post I seen thanks to share it. It is really what I wanted to see hope in future you will continue for sharing such a excellent post 야설

Also feel free to visit may web page 한국야동

koreayadongcom said...

Awesome dispatch! I am indeed getting apt to over this info, is truly neighborly my buddy. Likewise fantastic blog here among many of the costly info you acquire. Reserve up the beneficial process you are doing here. 야동

Also feel free to visit may web page 일본야동

japanyadongcom said...

I have to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in penning this blog. I’m hoping to check out the same high-grade blog posts by you later on as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own blog now 국산야동

Also feel free to visit may web page 야설

chinayadongnet said...

I am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site. 한국야동

Also feel free to visit may web page 야설

Unknown said...

Great post. I’m dealing with a few of these issues as well.. 토토

Unknown said...

토토사이트 Extremely intriguing online journal. A lot of web journals I see nowadays don't generally give anything that I'm keen on, however I'm most definitely inspired by this one. Recently felt that I would post and let you know.

Unknown said...

바카라사이트 If more people that write articles really concerned themselves with writing great content like you, more readers would be interested in their writings. Thank you for caring about your content.

Unknown said...

Very interesting info !Perfect just what I was looking for!
Here is my web page
온라인카지노

Linda smith said...

We at my assignment help deliver the finest assignments with the help of a reliable writer who takes down the content from scratch.

Dim4ksan said...

Now is the time that we can communicate with people from a distance, we fly into space and we can buying a russian wife. It is because of this opportunity that many men all over the world get to know and communicate with Russian girls. But buying a Russian wife you need to understand a lot of different nuances. One of which is help, you have to help your wife and support her in all her initiatives. I think there is no problem with that. I want to recommend to everyone this opportunity that can change your whole life.

pachinkosite.info said...

I was studying some of your articles on this site and I think this web site is really informative! Keep putting up. 파친코

Nick said...

I have been looking for this types of contents so I can utilize my time properly. Today, I found two good topic like Cyber Monday Web Hosting Deals and this one. There are really best.

Cristina Parker said...

Acadecraft is the reliable conversion partner to convert all flash based content into the mobile compatible format. Here, global clients receive affordable flash to html5 conversion services. Proficient and certified experts at this platform coverts games, activities, and simulations in HTML5 format. Also, Acadecraft delivers cost-effective solutions that convert content screens, simulations, and activities.
Storyline Translation Service
copy editing and proofreading services

David parker said...

Assignment Helper of great assignment helper.com are specifically tailored for today's students who have an extremely busy and gruelling schedule. Our young students have tons of work apart from their classwork and at times it feels humanly impossible to get all the things done and get the much needed eight hours of shut eye. Our homework writing experts assure you timely delivery with the highest degree of quality and precision.

Elle Flynn said...

Economics Assignment Help is all for the students and they certainly think more about the students than their own benefits, this platform is the perfect choice. They have kept the prices very cheap and convenient, so that, students can take help whenever necessary. Moreover, by opting for this particular platform, the students will be guaranteed of genuine and error free content every time. We are helping students globally for the last 6 years and looking forward for more.
Economics Assignment Help

123bet said...

Your article has made me more experienced and impressed. I hope you have more good posts. สมัครสมาชิก 123betting

Frank said...

it carries out the new framework. Write Me An Essay Leave the cloud alone productive in that it improves the duplicates of works for capacity economy, yet in addition for access economy. What's more, left the cloud alone legit and imaginative in isolating the expenses.

texasholdemsite.info said...

Everyone an extremely breathtaking chance to read from this blog. It is always so lovely and jam-packed with a great time. 포커게임

Forgot AOL Password said...

The article is very helpful and informative, so thank you so much for sharing this article and I hope that you will share more information about it.

Lillian J. Turner said...

Nice Blog. Thanks for sharing with us. Such amazing information.

Significance of privacy in the modern world of technology

Buy Assignment Online Uk said...

Assignmentdone.co.uk we will likely support students with their composition projects. At Buy Assignment Online UkIrrespective of whether you are an undergrad, Master’s or PhD student, our perfect group of master scholarly authors can proficiently make your paper irrespective of what field or claim you require.

Post a Comment